Since its publication in 2011, I've read many things of the book "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mom". But just until recently, I have read it. It has been a while since the last time I found a book that I can finish reading in a day even though reading is one of my favorite leisure activities in my spare time.
I know the book has generated a huge and controversial response, both positive and negative. The roar of opposition towards the author Amy Chua is the criticism of her child-raising way as mean, cruel, controlling and indifferent to her children's well-being. Some others, however, are big supporters of her parenting way and described her as a "Chinese hero". After reading her book, I found her description of the Chinese child-raising to be relatively objective, as I don't really see her bragging about her parenting but view it more as a self-reflecting memoir where the truths were presented. As Amy said, the book is self-parody. I have to say that I am very impressed by her nimble and funny writing styles full with intentional contradiction and shocking honesty. As is true to all other training methods, we cannot simply draw a conclusion that the Tiger Mom style is unbelievably unacceptable or worth promoting. It works for Amy, a successful Harvard-trained law professor at Yale, her siblings, and her older daughter Sophia, and many other Asian Americans, but may generate crisis among a lot of kids like Amy's younger daughter Lulu. All matters here is the issue of fit. While many people portrayed Amy as a cold-blooded mother who does not care about her children's happiness, Amy confronted it by emphasizing that her parenting way is strict but coupled with love and that she is preparing a better, more secure, and decent future for her children, which is the best demonstration of love. Even I could not say "mean" words as she did, I think her defense makes a lot of sense. Meanwhile, I admire how calm, confident, and brave Amy has been in responding people's criticisms while deep down, I believe she must be hurt and worried.
As with many Asians, this book resonated with me and brought me back to many memories I had with my mom. While I don't see my mom as that controlling, since she wasn't standing there to watch me finish my homework or playing table tennis, she has many unwritten rules that were exactly the same as Amy's. For example, if I brought home a second place in my class grade ranking, that's bad; if I watched TV, that's unacceptable; if I didn't win the city-level tournament, that's unforgivable. She barely yelled at me, even though she had a loud voice and sometimes it sounds like yelling but actually she was talking at a normal voice. She would give me this look that makes me felt like that I have just committed a crime. It is just like seeing lightening before having the storm and you know in the next few seconds, you will be wet if you do not run for now. She obviously had authority that made me scared. To prevent her punishment, which was actually cold treatment to me for a long time, I worked very hard and played table tennis three hours after work. I never went to play video games, or had sleepovers, or went out for movies, and those things I did not even think as options for my spare time. The lucky thing is that I almost brought home with the first place ranking in my class every semester and had won 15 city-level championships in table tennis since I was 6. Because of that, I feel safe that my mom would never check my homework or monitor me playing table tennis and that I will have own wonder world to read books I like in my spare time. When I looked back 15 years ago, I felt somewhat relieved that reading was the primary way I entertained myself rather than secretly doing something that might hurt me. My mom never checked my books either. She didn't have the time and attention on me as long as my grade is No. 1. This actually worked greatly for me since I liked being alone in my book world and did not want to open my heart to her or anyone else. I remembered in Amy's book, her well-behaved daughter Sophia told her when she was 17 that she felt going through the beginning of teenager was very tough and lonely. Amy was shocked since she did not notice the psychological change of her daughter even she spent hours and hours with Sophia. It is very common in a Chinese family that heart-to-heart talks are almost non-existing. When I was young, I did not even think opening heart to my mom was option nor something I should do. Coming back to the books, my mom didn't know what books I was reading, sometimes she may question the need to buy so many books, but she couldn't complain much since I satisfied her requirement on my grades and tournament. Just on one day, I was reading a well-known writer Yan Mo (Nobel literature winner, 2012)'s book named "Big Breasts and Wide Hips", a story between a mom and her eight daughters and one son. My mom somehow noticed the book's name, probably because it was so catching, and went almost outraged and questioned me if I've learned something dirty and if I was in a relationship. Of course not! But I was so scared by her loud voice and felt weak to defense myself. I simply cried. My mom thought I was admitting the "sin" I made and hit my figures with a ruler. I didn't remember how it ended on that day and I seemed to be too tried after crying for an hour and just went to sleep. On the second day, my mom wanted me to write a letter to guarantee that I wouldn't read "unhealthy" books like that. I am glad that I become sober on the second day and patiently explained to my mom what a famous and prize-winning write Yan is and how meaningful the story that book has. Here is a note, I explained all of these in writing, I didn't realize that how scared I could be even to defense myself to her face to face. I think that's an example of how Tiger Mom can push their kids away and create a unseen psychological distance with them.
Luckily, for now, as a grown-up and more mature woman, I have maintained a close relationship with my mom. Thinking back the way she has parented me, I feel gratitude, as the high standards she had for me make me more self disciplined, driven, and achievement-oriented. More importantly, I feel content, but I am not sure if I didn't have this Tiger style when I was young, I would be as happy as I am now.
Will I pass the same way to my future kids? Probably not that strict, but we will never know.

